TEXAS LEGISLATORS NAVIGATE THE COMPLEXITIES OF AI REGULATION
A Senate committee recently explored the intricacies of artificial intelligence (AI) during a nearly four-hour hearing, shedding light on Texas’s approach to regulating this rapidly advancing technology.
Concerns About AI
The Texas Senate Business and Commerce Committee highlighted concerns regarding the potential risks associated with AI, such as the dissemination of misinformation, biased decision-making, and infringements on consumer privacy. By the end of the hearing, some committee members concluded that Texas may need to implement regulations governing how private companies utilize AI technology.
Sen. Lois Kolkhorst, R-Brenham, emphasized the importance of safeguarding the public, stating, “If you really think about it, it’s a dystopian world we could live in. Our challenge is figuring out how to implement those safeguards.”
The Scope of Artificial Intelligence
Artificial intelligence encompasses various technologies, from chatbots that assist users through language processing to generative AI that creates original content. It can also automate decision-making processes, such as determining home insurance rates or evaluating job applicants. Additionally, AI is utilized to create digital replicas of artistic works.
According to Amanda Crawford, chief information officer for the Texas Department of Information Resources, over 100 of the 145 state agencies currently employ AI in some capacity. Crawford is part of the newly established AI Council, formed by Gov. Greg Abbott, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, and House Speaker Dade Phelan, to assess the use of AI in state agencies and evaluate the necessity of an ethical framework for AI applications. The council’s report is anticipated by the year’s end.
Impact on State Agencies
Leaders from various state agencies testified on the advantages of AI, noting significant time and cost savings. For instance, Edward Serna, executive director of the Texas Workforce Commission, shared that a chatbot implemented in 2020 has addressed 23 million inquiries. Likewise, Tina McLeod, information officer in the Attorney General’s Office, mentioned that their AI tool helps employees save at least an hour each week when managing lengthy child support cases.
However, some stakeholders raised concerns about potential negative impacts on Texans due to AI. Country singer Josh Abbott expressed worry that AI could replicate his voice for unauthorized song creations on platforms like Spotify, stating, “AI fakes don’t care if you’re famous. AI frauds and deep fakes affect everyone.”
The Call for Responsible AI Usage
Policy analyst Grace Gedye from Consumer Reports indicated that private companies have previously used biased AI models for crucial housing and employment decisions detrimental to consumers. She urged lawmakers to mandate audits for companies that rely on AI for decision-making processes, similar to New York City’s law requiring audits for automated employment tools, although the compliance rate has been low.
When crafting future legislation, officials must approach the matter delicately to avoid prohibiting beneficial AI applications while addressing associated risks, according to Renzo Soto, executive director of TechNet, which advocates for technology CEOs. “You almost have to look at it industry by industry.”
Texas has already enacted laws like the one in 2019 criminalizing misleading videos intended to influence elections and a 2023 law banning deep fake videos for pornographic purposes. As lawmakers contemplate future regulations, particular attention must be paid to First Amendment rights, as noted by attorney Ben Sheffner from the Motion Picture Association.
Throughout the hearing, legislators sought examples from other states and countries to inform their AI policy development. Currently, a patchwork of regulations at both state and federal levels attempts to manage AI usage but with limited success. California has proposed legislation that requires AI developers to mitigate “catastrophic harm” risks from their technologies, while Colorado has already passed regulations concerning AI usage in high-stakes areas like education, employment, and healthcare.
Upcoming Challenges and Developments
As discussions about AI regulation progress, it remains critical for Texas lawmakers to ensure they encourage innovation while protecting citizens from potential abuses of technology.
Get Your TribFest Tickets!
Don’t miss out on TribFest from September 5–7, featuring over 100 discussions with more than 300 speakers, including notable figures like Stacey Abrams, Colin Allred, and Nancy Pelosi. Secure your tickets now!
Support Independent Texas News
The Texas Tribune is committed to delivering fact-based journalism. Your support is essential to continue providing in-depth news and information. Consider making a donation to help sustain our nonprofit newsroom.
